Fresh seafood is the reason most people eat out on Marco Island. Grouper, stone crab, snapper, and shrimp show up on nearly every menu, and the best restaurants source directly from local waters. You'll find everything from upscale raw bars and Gulf-view dining rooms to no-frills fish houses where the daily catch is written on a whiteboard. If it swam this morning and you're eating it tonight, you're doing Marco Island right. These are the seafood restaurants worth your time. One of Marco’s chicest new restaurants. Although the decor is ‘upmarket’ the ambiance is friendly and relaxed. The menu offers a combination of a la carte, with a choice of a dozen sides and sauces to accompany your meat or fish selections, and all inclusive house specialties. The extensive… Read more An upscale coastal dining experience with a focus on fresh caught chef inspired seafood and oysters from around the world. The chic and unique atmosphere, adorned with contemporary design elements, provides the perfect backdrop for enjoying the incredible marina waterfront views. Whether you’re… Read more Locally owned and operated, provides a welcoming, family-friendly atmosphere with stunning waterfront views, perfect for enjoying their diverse menu of sushi, seafood, and classic American dishes. The large outdoor patio provides an ideal spot for soaking in the scenery, while a private dining room… Read more A locally owned restaurant renowned for its unparalleled service, top-shelf cocktails, and unique culinary masterpieces. Often said to offer the best local seafood on Marco Island, their culinary recipes are unmatched and can’t be found at any other restaurant on the island. With three distinct… Read more Experience upscale dining with a relaxed vibe at Sami’s! Serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner, this family-friendly favorite offers both indoor and outdoor seating, complete with a charming inside/outside bar. While the famous pizzas are a must-try, the menu also features gourmet steaks, chicken… Read more Experience the charm of Italy without the jet lag! Sophisticated taste blends into a family atmosphere where each guest will feel at home while enjoying signature dishes and carefully selected wines. The marble interior is complemented by mosaics, a mural of Leonardo Da Vinci’s artwork and a full… Read more Formerly The Old Marco Lodge Crab House under new owners as the Paradise Found Restaurant & Bar. Live music on the outside enlarged deck, seafood, great views of Big Marco River and live mermaids at weekends! Great salad bar. New Tiki Hut Bars. Free golf cart parking lot shuttle. In season open for… Read more Nestled on the waterfront in the charming fishing village of Goodland, Little Bar has been a cherished local tradition for over 47 years. Famous for its fresh, locally sourced seafood, quality steaks, and the best live music on the island, Little Bar offers a welcoming atmosphere and a diverse menu… Read more Happy Hour from 4.30 to 6.00 pm nightly at the bar. The Oyster Society brings 1920s glamor and sophistication to Marco in a casual and comfortable setting, combining a “Great Gatsby” theme with a nautical fusion. Offering a wide selection of fresh local seafood, shellfish, sushi and daily raw… Read moreSeafood Favorites
Restaurants in this collection
Marco Prime Steaks and Seafood
Deep Lagoon
Mango’s Dockside Bistro
Fin Bistro
Sami’s
DaVinci’s
Paradise Found Restaurant & Bar
Little Bar
The Oyster Society
Seafood Favorites v2Nico Moreno2026-05-06T20:11:16-04:00
From the Gulf
Curated collection
